Mudder Focker! Or something else?

Maranello said:

IMHO of course but...I found several PAA AS that are fantastic for healing & longevity of scent..CaD (similar but lighter than Fine's AB/Rive Guache, Al Fin is superb, however I found their Bay Rum way too heavy/spicy. PAA sample vials are tiny & uausually good for one use, keep in mind...you may want to spring for a couple of each scent you may be interested in to make sure you like.

RR Mudder Focker AS is easily one of my new favorites! It's based on Boellis Panama 1924 and definitely has a similar classy, powdery but masculine vibe to it. If you buy and don't like it, at less than $12 I'll gladly purchase a third bottle as a back up!

Click to expand...

Maranello said:

During warmer months I like T&H 1805, Agua Lavanda Puig (use the cologne as an AS), Fine Fresh Vetiver, & Fine Platinum

..and for the colder seasons enjoy Crown Shaving Co AS Tonic, both Dr Harris & AoS Sandalwoods, Wm Neumman & Co Heartwood, RR Baby Blue/Vitos Aftershave (honestly can't tell the difference)..both the Ogallala Bay Rum Vanilla & their BR Sandalwood, Alpa Fougere

I have an embarassing amount of AS splashes...and many favorites as well! hope this helps

Click to expand...

CzechCzar said:

I have been hunting for some time for an aftershave that has great skin conditioning properties (I have sensitive skin) and great, long lasting smell. I have a tiny sample of Floid Vigoroso and a bottle of Ogallala Bay Rum Vanilla as my gold standard. Nothing else has come close.

I have tried Myrsol (left my skin feeling too tight and not well enough moisturized), Razorock Baby Blue (great smell, didn't last long enough, Chiseled Face (alright skin conditioning, smell is fleeting). At the end of this restraint I am thinking of buying either some Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements samples, or risking it and buying a RR aftershave.

Can anyone comment as to the healing/scent longevity of PAA? And with RR, can anyone tell me what smells I would like? I love Bay Rum and the scent of Mudder Focker Soap. I kind of despise sandalwood, Stetson Cologne, and cowboy scents.

I hear that the RR Muther Focker AS is great. Can anyone confirm this?

What should I get asfaghsfjhs/??

Click to expand...

korgscrew said:

Try adding some glycerin to your aftershaves. To test it, put a little bit of glycerin on your palm then add some AS and apply. I've added it to most of my AS' now. With the ones I haven't, I just put a small drop of glycerin on my Paul before applying.

Click to expand...

global_dev said:

What's a cowboy scent? Like farm/field cowboy or suburban cowboy? I am intrigued as I have no idea as a northerner in the mid Atlantic. Is it earthy like hay and cow pies? Or "classic" like brut and old spice? Or is like saddle leather and tobacco?

Click to expand...