Any shaving soaps that smell like/similiar to old spice amber or Hollister so cal?

I would be ecstatic if a soap smelled like these scents! Anyone know of anything similar?

I know Old Spice amber has black currant and amber. Not sure what Hollister has. I've just gotten soaps that smell to traditional thus far. I thought for sure The Beach by PAA would have been new scented. Still had that old traditional smell. Please any suggestions?

Or any Halloween/Magic scented soaps?

Stirling spice may be worth a sniff...

http://www.stirlingsoap.com/stirling-spice-shave/

benzology said:

Stirling spice may be worth a sniff...

http://www.stirlingsoap.com/stirling-spice-shave/

Click to expand...

Ah, I don't like the classic old spice scent, I like their new scent, Amber. Thanks though!

Ahhh I see.... Apologies for that.

I'm a big fan of OS... seems it might be time to check out the new scent!

Dracula Untold said:

Or any Halloween/Magic scented soaps?

Click to expand...

Soapy Bathman Black Magic. It's superb. Smells spicy, Cologne type scent, woody, incense. One of my faves

Yes! Please do!

b_market said:

Soapy Bathman Black Magic. It's superb. Smells spicy, Cologne type scent, woody, incense. One of my faves

Click to expand...

Hmm I saw that one, looked pretty good. I was thinking about trying Dr Jon's Hex. http://www.drjonshandcraftedsoapco.com/shop/hex

Dracula Untold said:

Hmm I saw that one, looked pretty good. I was thinking about trying Dr Jon's Hex. http://www.drjonshandcraftedsoapco.com/shop/hex

Click to expand...

Don't see an ingredient list and haven't heard much about Dr John on here so I can't really comment on performance, but $15 for 2oz is quite pricey. Maybe someone else can comment on performance? I'd be a little wary to spend $7.50/oz without some reviews first.

This guy posted a review. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QRpNKdn-_7Y


Any beach scents other than PAA?

Bump

Amber is a very classic scent, now the OS Amber might have some other notes added to it, but you can find a few amber scented shave soaps.


http://phoenixartisanaccoutrements....enix-artisan-accoutrements-shaving-soap-amber

It's actually $14.95 for the 4oz size and $7.95 for the 2oz size, I may need to double check the photos.

domzals1 said:

Don't see an ingredient list and haven't heard much about Dr John on here so I can't really comment on performance, but $15 for 2oz is quite pricey. Maybe someone else can comment on performance? I'd be a little wary to spend $7.50/oz without some reviews first.

Click to expand...

jondeplin said:

It's actually $14.95 for the 4oz size and $7.95 for the 2oz size, I may need to double check the photos.

Click to expand...

I misread the top and saw the 2oz pictured, so I took the $15 price and the 2oz picture. Apologies!

It's no problem. We still aren't cheap at $3.75 an ounce, just didn't want you to thing I was totally off my rocker!

domzals1 said:

I misread the top and saw the 2oz pictured, so I took the $15 price and the 2oz picture. Apologies!

Click to expand...

I would look into RazoRock. I'm pretty sure they have some cologne scented soaps.

Ah cool, Dr Jon himself! Hey I don't mind the prices as long as the smell and performance justifys the pricing! Next payday I'll buy your 4oz. With shipping costs the 2oz is not worth it in my opinion >.< Do you think you could recreate the old spice amber scent? Another scent I'm fond of comes from this hair product called not your mothers beach babe. Stuff smells super fantastic!
http://www.ulta.com/ulta/browse/productDetail.jsp?productId=xlsImpprod3120617&categoryId=cat120026

I think the performance and fragrances are worth the cost of admission but I may be slightly biased. I'll be honest and tell you that I won't try to make fragrances similar to other things, I don't have any problem with soaps mimicking existing fragrances but it just isn't my thing. I have gone out of my way to make something new including the base ingredients, the packaging and the fragrances.

Dracula Untold said:

Ah cool, Dr Jon himself! Hey I don't mind the prices as long as the smell and performance justifys the pricing! Next payday I'll buy your 4oz. With shipping costs the 2oz is not worth it in my opinion >.< Do you think you could recreate the old spice amber scent? Another scent I'm fond of comes from this hair product called not your mothers beach babe. Stuff smells super fantastic!
http://www.ulta.com/ulta/browse/productDetail.jsp?productId=xlsImpprod3120617&categoryId=cat120026

Click to expand...

jondeplin said:

I think the performance and fragrances are worth the cost of admission but I may be slightly biased. I'll be honest and tell you that I won't try to make fragrances similar to other things, I don't have any problem with soaps mimicking existing fragrances but it just isn't my thing. I have gone out of my way to make something new including the base ingredients, the packaging and the fragrances.

Click to expand...

I recently purchased 2 of Jons soaps and I'm really digging both. Scents and performance are great imo. I plan on getting hex my next order. Give it a shot!

jondeplin said:

I think the performance and fragrances are worth the cost of admission but I may be slightly biased. I'll be honest and tell you that I won't try to make fragrances similar to other things, I don't have any problem with soaps mimicking existing fragrances but it just isn't my thing. I have gone out of my way to make something new including the base ingredients, the packaging and the fragrances.

Click to expand...

And I don't blame you one bit! I look forward to trying hex! The label is very appealing! I love magic and I love witches! You really peaked my interest with your labeling!