What is the Best Shave soap you've ever tried.

[Bestarrkin]

Cacharel pour l'homme.

Yes, it is my favorite too.

 

[jaguar]

My list of top soaps include Martin de Candre, Klar Seiffen Klassik, D.R. Harris Arlington, and Calani.

 

[mchad21]

MWF and Mike's. For value, gotta go with the Palmolive stick.

 

[xfumbler]

I haven't tried an extensive collection of soaps (and no creams at all) but of the about 9 I have, Razorock XXX is the best. The lather is great and the scent is awesome. When I heard it was no longer being made I added a replacement to my next order.

 

[mhdena]

AOS Lavender, Lemon, Sandalwood
Cella - still have
Harris Arlington - no longer in rotation
MdC -no longer in rotation
Tabac/Irish Moos- still have
Truefitt & Hill- no longer in rotation

All in rotation, all fabulous

Revised list

AOS
Mike's

 

[Graybeard57]

MB Dragon's Blood

 

[lt114]

I've got an unused puck of vintage Yardley's on the way. I'm excited to see if it lives up to its substantial reputation.

 

[FL shaver]

Tabac, though it isn't my favorite. I like La Toja and MWF more. I have tried MdC, and put it just below those 3. I don't think MdC has the same slickness. I haven't tried AOS yet, and I'll bet it is fantastic. Vintage Old Spice performs nearly as well as my top 3, too.

 

[Bravoure]

Martin de Candre hands down. I have never once been even slightly let down by the lather produced from that soap.

 

[Toddy]

Based on performance and price, Arko

General all rounder MWF and Tabac

 

[Phillips]

OMEGA!

 

[Acmemfg]

Best SOAP...would have to be La Toja Manantiales. I qualify that by saying Cella is not (to me) a "soap" in the true sense, none of the softer soap products are. They are a hybrid of sorts.

If I must lump Cella into the soap phylum...then Cella it is

 

[BigBull]

The Fat in my den. L'Occitane Cade has recently crept in...

I'm gonna revise my list too:

Mike's Natural
MWF
Cella

 

[rm71]

Speick
La Toja
Euro Palmolive

 

[ochahine]

Best so far for me has definitely been Mike's.

 

[delamain]

Tabac is the best I have tried but I've only gone through a couple... I've got a lot of the old standards on my list.

 

[FL shaver]

EDIT:

I see I've been here before!

 

[jpress76]

Queen Charlottes Vostok. A menthol kick in the teeth for those hard to get out of bed mornings. Great with any aftershave. Slick and cushioned lather.

 

[axman]

MDC has been the best so far. Then AOS.

 

[Eric83]

Mitchell's Wool Fat (only been using a week, but great result's)
AOS Sandalwood
Proraso