For the price point, I don't think you can go wrong. The Old Tub is a go-to for me and I enjoy it neat or with a rock or two. It is smooth enough to drink straight so I have never attempted to mix it.The only one I really liked was the "Double Aged" black bottle. The regular white one my father drank some, always gave me bad heartburn and generally an upset tummy with just a shot or two (really not that much at all was bad news for me).
How do those two compare? Smooth neat or over rocks?