What's new

Alternate flashlight to a mini maglite needed

I carry a Streamlight Nano. The mini maglight LED, 2AA used to live in my nightstand. The mini maglight LED 3AA used to live in my car. This morning I needed more light than the Nano offers to inspect my chimney before the first fire of the fall, and was disappointed by a lack of light from my two favorite flashlights.

I admit I have not used them in several months. Both were off. One was fully climate controlled, the other not so much. The batteries swelled and jammed into the case. Now thinking I might get lucky and the batteries were intact I threw the Maglites into the freezer for later, and grabbed the backup light out of the shower (no windows in that room, kinda dark when the power goes out) It hangs out on the robe hook on the door.

The bathroom backup light is an old Radio Shack rubber covered waterproof flashlight that I think needs a new o-ring. It is equipped with an old-style Maglight 2 to 6 cell LED replacement bulb, and being a 2AA is rather anemic (heck it was anemic with 3 D cells driving it) , but much more powerful than my Streamlight Nano.

So I check the chimney (I think I can go at least another year without seeping since it is a masonry fireplace that is useless to heat with.) So I have a little fire. I cheer up some. I lament that I will pack the damper with insulation bags when the snow flies. Alas.

Now this afternoon I pull the flashlights out of the freezer. One solid thump on a board each and not quite all the batteries come out. The top most cell in both lights ruptured, and the contents sealed most of the way around. I ain't getting that out! The other 3 cells were obviously swelled considerably, but because the contents are a "liquid" substance great contraction with cold will pull the case in just enough to get the unburst batteries out. I have done this several times over the years to all battery sizes and many Maglites...usually with much better luck.

So I need some assistance. I am in the market for at least 2 inexpensive flashlights. I would really prefer under $30, but under $50 will do fine.

I have looked at the available "tac" lights and I am overwhelmed, especially when $50 won't touch most of the market. I don't really need a tactical light though.

I like the rugged nature of the Maglite. I am becoming more and more appalled by how close the battery fits the tube, and how impossible the batteries become to remove. I am looking for:

2AA or similar size frame as in pocket size. I expect to be under cars, in the crawl space, and maybe down the river at night.
a tube that will not jam batteries
powerful beam, focusing a plus. The 3W LED Mag light is adequate.
Different power output levels is a plus, but not required unless much brighter than the mini Maglite
waterproof - but not necessarily a dive light - just in case I drop it in the sump well I want the light to still work.
Durable - metal is nice, but heavy plastic is acceptable. I expect 10 ft drops onto turf, gravel, and concrete.
long life - I think this limits me to LED lamps. 2.5+ hours on high and over 20 on low was the mini maglite.
A tube that will not jam batteries!

Thank you for any insight.

Phil
 
Hi Phil, check out the Streamlight polytac line. I have the small upright held model. They're amazing! For something cigar size, the stylus models are durable and give good output for the size. Too bad they were both stolen from my glovebox.
 
get a rechargeable that uses 18650 battery with the cree led. they can be had for around 25 to 30 each if you look I have a single cell and a dual cell on high the double lasts around 1 1/2 to 2 hrs and the single cell is comparable to the same. yes they are a little bigger than the maglites but the light is unreal.
 
Cree 3w zoomable torch on ebay (total knock off) but for 3 bucks you can buy 10 of them. I bought a couple and theyre bulletproof
 
Grab a head lamp. They are amazing in all circumstances and leave your hands free. Petzl and Princeton make excellent ones. They have ones with a red light option which is great at night when you don't want to blind everyone around you.
 
Last edited:
But another maglight. You know how tough they are. If you need more light and long run time step up to C or D batterie maglight. The LED bulbs make a big difference.
 
I never got on with Maglites, they always broke when I really needed them. The casings are great, just not to internals. Switches were first to go, batteries would be so tight that they bent the mechanisms and left them permanently damaged. They despised being anywhere near a damp environment! I went through a few LED units as they progressed in quality, mainly Prineton. The likes of Coast, LED Lenser, etc are very good units for the money. Petzl head units are pretty amazing, built really well and are fantastic in terms of battery life. You don't need to spend big dollars to get big quality.
 
I do carry a Streamlight Stylus Pro in my shirt pocket. I'm a fire prevention officer and i use it on a daily basis... It packs a lot of punch for the size !
 
I have a little Fenix LD01 on my keychain, uses a single AAA battery, 3 modes- 3,26,72 lumens
Great little light and well made, have a look here
 
I picked this up last year at Depot after Xmas when they had it on clearance. I paid about $4 for it and it's pretty awesome.

proxy.php
 
I love how help threads build here. It is wonderful. I have googled everything people have mentioned.

I have an Energizer water proof headlamp. While I doubt it is water proof enough to go swimming with, it has tolerated rain just fine. It is cheap, really bright, and has worked well for me when I needed it. The red function I have never really used. I forgot about it yesterday though, it doesn't get much love. I think I'll put it in the car.

The Princeton Tec flashlights look interesting. I think the Amp might be what I want.

I ordered a $12 Ultrafire T6 off ebay (with rechargeable batteries and charger). I still have budget left.

Phil
 
You really can't go wrong with Fenix, or Surefire. There are many in that type of catagory. If you want to go with US made there are many options as well. I prefer US made, and custom. Here are my favorites:

http://peakledsolutions.net/

http://www.hdslights.com/

http://store.muyshondt.net/shop/

http://www.darksucks.com/

http://candlepowerforums.com/vb/showthread.php?222118-The-Titanium-quot-Haiku-quot

The Haiku is my favorite for EDC during the work week, I've got several in different configurations. For heavier use I love my HDS Ra 170T.
The light that was the most useful though during a recent 3 day black out we had was the Muyshondt Aeon. It worked perfectly, and with a 40 hour runtime on low you can't go wrong with it.

I also run Li-ion rechargables in all my lights.
 
You really can't go wrong with Fenix, or Surefire. There are many in that type of catagory. If you want to go with US made there are many options as well. I prefer US made, and custom. Here are my favorites:

http://peakledsolutions.net/

http://www.hdslights.com/

http://store.muyshondt.net/shop/

http://www.darksucks.com/

http://candlepowerforums.com/vb/showthread.php?222118-The-Titanium-quot-Haiku-quot

The Haiku is my favorite for EDC during the work week, I've got several in different configurations. For heavier use I love my HDS Ra 170T.
The light that was the most useful though during a recent 3 day black out we had was the Muyshondt Aeon. It worked perfectly, and with a 40 hour runtime on low you can't go wrong with it.

I also run Li-ion rechargables in all my lights.

Jewelry right there. Priced like jewelry. Like fine jewelry I am sure it is worth every penny. I might have to have a copper beta qrv2... need vs want, I WANT.

I would fear loosing everything else.

Phil
 
I've given up on expensive flashlights. I have a bunch of these in the cars, camping, and around the house.

http://www.harborfreight.com/27-led-portable-worklight-flashlight-67227.html

I bought the first one on a whim, due to the miniscule price. It was so cheap that I asked the clerk if the batteries could be replaced. She didn't know, but opened one up to check. The first thing that I noticed was that the screws holding the cover were machine screws and went into what appeared to be brass inserts rather than being sheet metal screws jammed into plastic. These flashlights are sleepers, quality wise.
 
Top Bottom