Winter coat recommendations

cluelessdude · Sep 24, 2012

This will be for winters here in Toronto, Canada. Keep in mind it doesn't get too cold here as of late however here are my requirements:

- 100% wool
- Grey color that will work with brown shoes as well (probably means no black buttons?)
- length should be that of a peacoat, not looking for those long coat lengths or neither a bomber
- slim fit

I already have a black J Crew peacoat so looking for something else as that doesn't work with brown shoes. Price range is $150-$300.

srk1103 · Sep 24, 2012

I live in New England so I'm used to cold winters. I'm tall and thin so I have a hard time finding clothing long enough. I went to Men's Wearhouse and got a really nice charcoal winter coat much like this one. They were even able to make the sleeves a little longer for me!

http://www.menswearhouse.com/shop/p...751_700108278_-1_700000436_____noSpecialSizes

rushchairman · Sep 24, 2012

http://www.spiewak.com/fashion/collection/AW12/men/

spiewak offers a great looking / mixed use option.

jones2289 · Sep 24, 2012

You may give Schott a shot:

http://www.schottnyc.com/products/men/peacoat/mens-slim-fitting-wool-peacoat.htm

While I haven't ordered from them, I believe the company is highly regarded here on B&B. Hopefully some others with more experience can chime in. I was actually debating ordering a pea coat from them last winter when I found a deal on one at TJ Maxx that was too good to pass up. They are very responsive to email, and seem to be a "mom & pop" type operation. Their website has a forum where you can post questions, and Gail with their customer service team checks the posts frequently.

I found the below information on their forum, but this post was from 2008. I'm not sure if they still use the same distributor, but if you're interested, you may give it a try.

CANADA

Distribitions A&F Inc.

Gary Skolnik

Montreal Canada

Phone # 514-904-6770
E-mail: [email protected]

cluelessdude · Sep 24, 2012

jones2289 said:
You may give Schott a shot:

http://www.schottnyc.com/products/men/peacoat/mens-slim-fitting-wool-peacoat.htm

While I haven't ordered from them, I believe the company is highly regarded here on B&B. Hopefully some others with more experience can chime in. I was actually debating ordering a pea coat from them last winter when I found a deal on one at TJ Maxx that was too good to pass up. They are very responsive to email, and seem to be a "mom & pop" type operation. Their website has a forum where you can post questions, and Gail with their customer service team checks the posts frequently.

I found the below information on their forum, but this post was from 2008. I'm not sure if they still use the same distributor, but if you're interested, you may give it a try.

CANADA

Distribitions A&F Inc.
Gary Skolnik
Montreal Canada
Phone # 514-904-6770
E-mail: [email protected]

Interesting you bring that up. I actually had been looking at their car coat in grey:

http://www.epauletshop.com/servlet/the-431/'Wool-Double-Zip-Car/Detail

It's definitely in the running...

benvh · Sep 24, 2012

I have a Spiewak peacoat and a wool jacket and would highly recommend them. Good quality and reasonable price (at least when I bought mine a few years back).

Ben

thebikingengineer · Sep 24, 2012

+1 on the Schott recommendation. I was very close to buying this coat for myself, but then I moved to Southern California, rendering a Peacoat rather ineffective. That's a buy once sort of coat, you won't be sorry.

professorchaos · Sep 24, 2012

cluelessdude said:
This will be for winters here in Toronto, Canada. Keep in mind it doesn't get too cold here as of late however here are my requirements:

- 100% wool
- Grey color that will work with brown shoes as well (probably means no black buttons?)
- length should be that of a peacoat, not looking for those long coat lengths or neither a bomber
- slim fit

I already have a black J Crew peacoat so looking for something else as that doesn't work with brown shoes. Price range is $150-$300.

If that isn't the kiss of death (cold winter), I don't know what is.

Duffle Coat gets my nod of approval.

GMZ · Sep 27, 2012

I enjoy my Filson Mackinaw Cruiser when conditions permit.

Doc4 · Sep 27, 2012

Is this for wearing over a suit, or for casual?

Trouthunter · Sep 27, 2012

Filson, without any hesitation. I own several filson wool, waxed canvas and non-waxed canvas coats and love them all. Their new peacoat style fits very well and is long enough to cover a suit coat, so works for casual and work wear. Charcoal is very nice. A true "10" and something you will truly wear your entire life - or able to sell later if you want a change.

jaguar · Sep 27, 2012

Yet another recommendation for Filson products. They are top quality and will last a lifetime. Filson offers classic styling, a choice of superb fabrics, and most of their products are made in the United States.

benvh · Oct 25, 2012

If it's really that cold I'd go Canada Goose. I got one last winter and it's amazing. My heavy wool coat doesn't come close (unfortunately in price, also).

Ben

joshua1970 · Oct 25, 2012

i'll also cast my vote for Filson. great quality, they last forever.

RobAtSGH · Nov 3, 2012

Fidelity and Sterlingwear are always worth a look, as well. I was eyeballing a Fidelity in dark khaki this afternoon, in fact.

thunder54 · Nov 3, 2012

Chiming in on Filson. I have a charcoal double Mackinaw cruiser that goes with just about everything I own. I wear it to church all winter long.

Search

Winter coat recommendations

cluelessdude

srk1103

rushchairman

jones2289

Distribitions A&F Inc.

Gary Skolnik

Montreal Canada

cluelessdude

Distribitions A&F Inc.

Gary Skolnik

Montreal Canada

benvh

thebikingengineer

professorchaos

GMZ

Doc4

Stumpy in cold weather

Trouthunter

jaguar

benvh

joshua1970

RobAtSGH

thunder54

Similar threads