By the variety expressed here you can see that there are a lot of creams out there that perform very satisfactorily. It is subjective, you need to buy several of the abovementioned, to find your fave.
Wander down to your local mall and hit up Bath and Body Works. They have a very small men's section and sell tubes of shave cream. It is made by Proaso and is supposed to be their house product rebranded. Works really well and truth be told, the only thing I use anymore
Two come to mind for me.
GFT coconut and Xpec. Followed closely by Tobs and Boutique Palmyra. The margin of error with the above three is generous that one doesn't have to get it perfect in order to have a slick lather. That's another plus with them.