I guess this is going to depend on what you consider a manly smell. The GF smelled Tabac when I first got it and went "ohhh that's manly, I like it" While other people feel that while the shave you get from Tabac is excellent it needs to be aired out in your garage for a month before being allowed inside. T&Hs Grafton I find very nice and lets be honest is there anything more manly than Old Spice?
+ 1 on Tabac and +1 on the T&H Grafton,good enough for Sir Winston Churchill (manly enough at least until I can find out what Patton or Teddy Roosevelt used)good enough for me.
Modern classic Old Spice is plenty manly but if you can get hold of some vintage pre formula change(Shultan) or Indian Old Spice you've just kicked up the manly by 20%.