What's new

KCJ blades compared : Russia vs. China

KCG Comparison Russia vs. China

This shave was a test of blades using the KC Gillette made in Russia and the KC Gillette made in China. With the 3rd and final pass I used a PermaSharp (4). The KCG’s were each loaded into a Rockwell 6S using plate #R4. 2 days of facial hair growth. The Russian KCG blade was used on the right side of my face and the Chinese KCG blade was used on the left side of my face. Same preparation and software used on both sides. First pass was WTG. Second pass was XTG face and upper mouth, ATG lower mouth/chin, and XTG upper neck and WTG again on the mid to lower neck. My final pass was the same as my second however I changed to the PermSharp blade as I was not overly happy with the results of the KCG blades. My usual shave is a 2 pass with touchups as previously described.

I had higher expectations of the blade made in Russia because all the Gillette blades I’ve used that were made in Russia have been very good. I had lower expectations of the blade made in China given my poor results in the past using Chinese manufactured blades. I would describe the Russian blade as a bit smoother but surprisingly less efficient. The Chinese blade gave me some tugging and a “tinny” sound/feeling, especially on the first pass, but it did seem to be a bit more efficient than the Russian blade. After the first pass there was noticeably more residual whiskers on the right side of my neck and chin. The second pass did seem to even things out a bit, however I experienced a tiny weeper from the Russian blade on my second pass on the crease of the chin/mouth. The weeper was gone by the time I finished my shave. There was a little post shave alum stinging on both sides of my neck but no real redness or signs of irritation.

As for the packaging, the Russian blade was only lightly stamped on one side and had more glue than the Chinese blade which was more boldly stamped on both sides and had less glue.

For context, I have had excellent results with Russian GSB, Nacet, Permasharp, Gillette Platinum and the USA made Personna - not necessarily in any order. I don’t usually do well with Feather blades either but my last shave using the Karve Bison and Feather was very good.

My honest opinion is that I didn’t really like these blades based on this one shave experience but if I had to use them I could get by. That being said, this was only one shave using these KCG blades so take it with a grain of salt. Happy shaves! 🪒

Some pics along the way. Keep in mind, I think the phone reverses the images so my left and right are opposites (I marked which side is which).

IMG_1891.jpeg
IMG_1894.jpeg
IMG_1899.jpegIMG_1903.jpegIMG_1904.jpegIMG_1917.jpeg
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1893.jpeg
    IMG_1893.jpeg
    862.1 KB · Views: 1
  • IMG_1897.jpeg
    IMG_1897.jpeg
    1.9 MB · Views: 0
Blades seem to be the most variable part of the shaving comfort/performance equation. People will have different opinions based on their hair, skin, days of growth, and durability/longevity expectations.

I tested over 45 blades in 2024 using subjective measures. I used the same blade for a week, roughly 4 shaves, and I used many Gillette blades as well as Chinese brands. (List here: The 2024: 1-Blade, 1-Week, *Daily Shaving Adventure - https://www.badgerandblade.com/forum/threads/the-2024-1-blade-1-week-daily-shaving-adventure.647586/post-12909227)

The KCG (China) emerged as my third favorite blade. This just goes to show that well, opinions vary. This doesn't mean I found the original post by @Jaybyrd invalid or uninteresting. Quite the contrary.
 
Blades seem to be the most variable part of the shaving comfort/performance equation. People will have different opinions based on their hair, skin, days of growth, and durability/longevity expectations.

I tested over 45 blades in 2024 using subjective measures. I used the same blade for a week, roughly 4 shaves, and I used many Gillette blades as well as Chinese brands. (List here: The 2024: 1-Blade, 1-Week, *Daily Shaving Adventure - https://www.badgerandblade.com/forum/threads/the-2024-1-blade-1-week-daily-shaving-adventure.647586/post-12909227)

The KCG (China) emerged as my third favorite blade. This just goes to show that well, opinions vary. This doesn't mean I found the original post by @Jaybyrd invalid or uninteresting. Quite the contrary.

I agree with you 100%. It also wasn’t a super fair trial, this was only one shave. Thanks for sharing your link! 👍

Oh and I agree with your #1 and #2 blades, they are excellent!
 
Valid point! Even from a tuck I suppose we could get a one off bad blade that would foil our science projects 😉 my family thinks I’m nuts, lining stuff up and taking photos…I tell them it’s all in the name of research and development to help my fellow man and future generations of wet shavers achieve greatness 🤣
Comparing blades is always fun IMO!!

That said, I prefer to compare several blades from a variety of tucks as there can be batch to batch variation.
 
As for the packaging, the Russian blade was only lightly stamped on one side ...
The Russian KCG blades I have used were laser etched so no ink at all and the Chinese KCG are printed in ink. Is that how your Russian KCG blades are (laser etched)? Or did you mean they are lightly inked?

I really liked the Russian KCG a lot but I never bought very many of them because there was no 100 pack pricing. I stocked up on Russian GSB and Perma-Sharp so I'm set for life :)

I did buy 100 Chinese KCG and I haven't learned to love them yet. They are very good, just not as enjoyable for me as my favorites which are same as what you named (Russian GSB, Nacet, Perma-Sharp, Gillette Platinum and USA Personna)
 
Yes sir, I believe I may not have realized the difference between inking and etching but it does appear the Russian blades are more etched on one side and the Chinese blades are inked on both sides. Nice choices on the GSB’s, definitely a favorite and I stocked a decent amount as well 👍
The Russian KCG blades I have used were laser etched so no ink at all and the Chinese KCG are printed in ink. Is that how your Russian KCG blades are (laser etched)? Or did you mean they are lightly inked?

I really liked the Russian KCG a lot but I never bought very many of them because there was no 100 pack pricing. I stocked up on Russian GSB and Perma-Sharp so I'm set for life :)

I did buy 100 Chinese KCG and I haven't learned to love them yet. They are very good, just not as enjoyable for me as my favorites which are same as what you named (Russian GSB, Nacet, Perma-Sharp, Gillette Platinum and USA Personna)
 
As many of the members here know, quite often I am a critic. So, this will be one of those times.

1. Using a Perma-sharp for a third pass, even though you usually do 2 passes only. This was supposed to be a comparison of the two KCG blades.
So, your photo named "The End" reflects the result with the Perma-Sharp (3d pass) not the two KCG blades.

2. The left-right photo reversal thing will be confusing for some members most certainly.

By all means take this as constructive criticism and not bashing. 🖖
 
Top Bottom