Trumper Rose is a great cream-in fact, my favorite. The TOBS rose cream has a very nice scent and is an excellent product. Although I prefer the Trumper Rose, I wouldn't hesitate to recommend it. The Salter product also has a very pleasant, Tea Rose scent. As with the other Salter creams I've tried, it falls a bit short of the Trumper and TOBS creams in terms of "slickness" and cushioning on my face, although still acceptable. I haven't tried the DR Harris rose, so no further comment on it. As for the T&H cream, it has a pleasant scent; however, I like the Trumper, TOBS, and Salter scents better. Also, in my experience T&H creams seem to provide a bit less "protection". I know that sounds a bit vague, but I'm more prone to small nicks and some razor rash when I use them than with the others, especially Trumper and TOBS. In short, I'm not as partial to T&H as most forum members seem to be.
I am very fond of TOBS rose cream and GFT rose soap and use them regularly. I have yet to try the Salter or GFT rose creams. The TOBS SC is one that will always be in my rotation. I have a chunk of the Klar Kabinett shave soap that has a nice rose scent and performs well.