Aftershaves that you consider to be keepers

[Seattle]

Pinaud Clubman and Bay Rum
Speick (but it seems to magnify redness from razor burn lately)
Alt-Innsbruck
Musgo Real (the absolute most healing AS, but the smell, which is great, is too intense for business and the weird residual stickiness is annoying).
Skin Bracer

 

[Graybeard57]

All Capt's Choice
Clubman

 

[Snargle]

Here's mine:

Speick
Swiss Pitralon
Alt-Innsbruck (a cologne, an aftershave, or both? Great stuff any way!)
Captains Choice Lime (the first lime AS I actually like)
Aqua Velva
Vi-Jon Dollar Store Old Spice knock-off (I couldn't tell the difference between this and the current P&G OS)
English Leather (for those days when I want to recall my misspent youth)

 

[gundy]

1. English Leather
2. brute
3. aqua velva ice sport

 

[Rohrbach]

So far my keepers are:
Speick
GFT Skin Food Lemon Extract
Proraso Splash and Balm
RR Aftershave Wax

 

[KlausSchulze]

Splash:
Speick
Penhalligon's Blenheim Bouquet
Pinaud Clubman
(next on purchase list is D.R. Harris Sandalwood AS, Floid Blue and Aque Velva Ice Blue

Thick Stuff:
Geo F. Trumper Skinfood Lime then Sandalwood
AoS Lavender AS balm

 

[The Count of Merkur Cristo]

Another vote here for Pinuad and for me...it's Clubman Citrus Musk (my one only 'go-to' scent)!

"Hard work is the aftershave [and eau de cologne] of accomplishment". Author Unknown

 

[babydials]

WM Neuman 1911
Musco Real Classic

 

[shevek]

Of the modest set of 12 that I currently own, I'd only consider these as must-owns:

HBG Sandalwood
Speick
CC Bay Rum

Speick is the only AS that I've actually re-upped so far. CC I find is the most healing in my collection.
HBG Sandalwood to me is extremely underrated. The price is extremely reasonable at <$8 and the smell is fantastic.

 

[mcdidher]

Clubman
Shulton Old Spice
Ogallala Bay Rum

 

[smoothie72]

Speick
Proraso
Musgo
Clubman SR
Alt Innsbruck
SCS (all of them)
Rose of Bulgaria
Sah Zefros
A/V

 

[Deltaboy]

AV ICE BLUE, Skin Bracer, Florida water , and Stetson.

 

[5savages]

I mostly use balms, but here are the spaces I really enjoy

Myrsol Agua Balsamica
Ogallala Bay Rum Co - Any flavor
Aubrey Organics Northwoods
Nivea Energy

 

[Catalin]

With splashes I seem to have an Iberian fixation:

Myrsol Agua Balsamica
Musgo Real
La Toja

For balms I like

Musgo Real
AOS Lavender (gel)
Speick AS Balm (for its great healing properties)

 

[Chadao]

All of these are about the scent:

Yves Saint Laurent L'Homme with Vetiver as a component I really like this
4711 I get a hint of tobacco
Sir Irisch Moos scent very much like the shave cream which I adore
Dominica Bay Rum my favorite Bay Rum
Lilac Vegetal how could I ever not include The Veg on my list

 

[California Cajun]

• Alt Innsbruck
  Aqua Velva Musk
  Mennen Skin Bracer
  Clubman
  Lilac Vegetal
  Gillette Cool Wave
  Sir Irisch Moos
  Tabac
  Pashana
  Bay Rum

 

[kingknight]

I prefer aftershaves complimented by soaps, creams, and balms of the same scent.

1. Speick
2. D.R. Harris Arlington
3. La Toja