Osage Rub or Clubman Pinaud 
Sometimes I add a bit of Thayers Lemon Witch Hazel to mix things up.
Sometimes I add a bit of Thayers Lemon Witch Hazel to mix things up.
Aftershaves that you consider to be keepers
- Thread starter Luc
- Start date
Clubman Original.
And anything else from Clubman.
And anything else from Clubman.
1. D.R. Harris Arlington and Windsor
2. Speik
3. St Charles Refined
4. AV Ice Blue
5. Pinaud Citrus Musk
6. Razorock Baby Blue
2. Speik
3. St Charles Refined
4. AV Ice Blue
5. Pinaud Citrus Musk
6. Razorock Baby Blue
There are lots of great aftershaves, but only one that I know I'll be keeping around forever. For me it's witch hazel.
1) Proraso (not the reformulation)
2) Speick
3) DR Harris Arlington
4) RR King Louis splash
5) Skin Bracer
6) Aqua Velva Ice Blue
7) Nivea Blue Energy splash
8) Indian Old Spice
9) Pinaud Clubman
10) Aqua Velva Ice Sport
2) Speick
3) DR Harris Arlington
4) RR King Louis splash
5) Skin Bracer
6) Aqua Velva Ice Blue
7) Nivea Blue Energy splash
8) Indian Old Spice
9) Pinaud Clubman
10) Aqua Velva Ice Sport
Clubman
Skin Bracer
DR Harris Arlington
And sometimes Indian OS, but I have to be in the right mood.
There are a lot I would like to try, but have not been able to source here in Oz. Actually, I can't get my top two here either, but have survived thanks to the generosity of the members here.
Skin Bracer
DR Harris Arlington
And sometimes Indian OS, but I have to be in the right mood.
There are a lot I would like to try, but have not been able to source here in Oz. Actually, I can't get my top two here either, but have survived thanks to the generosity of the members here.
Last edited:
Clubman, Floid Blue are the only ones I refill.
Aqua Velva
Aqua Velva Musk
Shulton Old Spice
Vintage Avon (any scent)
Pinaud Clubman
Pinaud Citrus Musk
Pinaud Special Reserve
Bootleggers Bay Rum
Skin Bracer
Osage Rub
Florida Water
Grey Flannel
Paul Sebastian
Aqua Velva Musk
Shulton Old Spice
Vintage Avon (any scent)
Pinaud Clubman
Pinaud Citrus Musk
Pinaud Special Reserve
Bootleggers Bay Rum
Skin Bracer
Osage Rub
Florida Water
Grey Flannel
Paul Sebastian
Antique Hoosier
“Aircooled”
Going to be looking for a new one soon..... If funds were no object, Floris JF splash by a country mile.... Proraso Splash is great but I've only owned the old version.
I have 23 different after-shave splashes and balms in my cabinet. My clear favorite is Speick ASL, and I'm currently on my third bottle since first trying it a few years ago. The one I use the next most often is Floid Vigoroso, but when it runs out, I plan on trying Floid Blue, as the Vigoroso has more menthol than I prefer. I picked up a bottle of Captain's Choice Lime last week, and so far, I'm impressed. In summary, those after-shaves I'm sure to buy again;
1. Speick
2. AV Ice Blue
Those I'll probably buy;
3. Captain's Choice Lime
4. Floid Vigoroso
Mike
1. Speick
2. AV Ice Blue
Those I'll probably buy;
3. Captain's Choice Lime
4. Floid Vigoroso
Mike
Aqua Velva Ice Blue, Mennen Skin Bracer, and Floid Classic
Clubman, Aqua Velva, and Alt-Innsbruck.
Captain's Choice Bay Rum
I'm still very much in a "try-it-out" phase when it comes to aftershaves. Honestly, I don't know that I'm going to be stocking any of the aftershaves I currently use. I mean, I like the Classic Clubman and the Captain's Choice well enough, but I still need to experiment within those product lines to pick a favorite (or two...). And I have yet to dip my toes into the pools of Floid, Ogallala, or Master products 
...or decide if I prefer AV Ice Blue or Skin Bracer (or both..) Sigh...
I guess the best I can do is:
-some kinda Clubman
-one of the Captain's Choice flavors
-Pre de Provence balm
...or decide if I prefer AV Ice Blue or Skin Bracer (or both..) Sigh...I guess the best I can do is:
-some kinda Clubman
-one of the Captain's Choice flavors
-Pre de Provence balm
St Charles Lime Splash - only approx. $11.00. Aramis Splash. St. Charles Dagger Splash. PVIBR
Pinaud Lilac Vegetal
Sir Irisch Moos
4711
Dominica Bay Rum
Yves Saint Laurent
Sir Irisch Moos
4711
Dominica Bay Rum
Yves Saint Laurent
Like a lot of folks here I went a little crazy for a while with ASAD and I have around 40 or so, but these are the ones I reach for the most and will refill immediately.
Speick- have yet to try anything better as far as healing/soothing goes. This is medicine for your face.
Alt Innsbruck- love the scent, love the menthol
The Veg- yes it initially smells like cat urine, but the dry down is awesome, routinely the one I get complimented the most for wearing and I have both Floris and Creed AS in my cabinet.
Floid Vigoroso- classic scent and very cooling
Skin Bracer- has replaced Clubman as my favorite drugstore "Barbershop" AS.
Speick- have yet to try anything better as far as healing/soothing goes. This is medicine for your face.
Alt Innsbruck- love the scent, love the menthol
The Veg- yes it initially smells like cat urine, but the dry down is awesome, routinely the one I get complimented the most for wearing and I have both Floris and Creed AS in my cabinet.
Floid Vigoroso- classic scent and very cooling
Skin Bracer- has replaced Clubman as my favorite drugstore "Barbershop" AS.
In order of my preferences:
Myrsol Blue
Pinaud Clubman
Old Spice Classic
Floid Blue
Myrsol Formula F Extra
Frank
Myrsol Blue
Pinaud Clubman
Old Spice Classic
Floid Blue
Myrsol Formula F Extra
Frank
Proraso (green) and Lilac Vegetal.
At one point or another I had almost every one of these, either a full bottle or a sample from Gary's (Gary's Sample Shop is a wonderful way to try quite a few of these without buying a full bottle first.) When I discovered Floid Blue, it scent triggers such a strong happy memory of a babershop from the past, that I have given up the rest and just use that every day.
