Well, I just received my first horsehide strop, a 2.5" TM Notovan plain Chocolate one. Notovan is his name for, "not cordovan," but a similar finishing process. Very supple and slick compared to my 3" Mountain Mikes Bridal leather strop or my 3" Latigo strop, so yes it is a fine leather...all depends on how it is finished and dressed. If you read the stickies above about need vs want, you'll gain more insight about the different leathers. Good luck!