Rank these Soaps on Performance

Hey guys. Curious to see what everyone thinks. Let's rank these soaps on performance. Like ease of lather, lather quality, slickness, cushion, post-shave. Not necessarily scent or customer service. If you haven't used them all, just rank the ones you have used. Let's go! Woo!

Barrister and Mann
Catie's Bubbles
Cold River Soap Works
Dapper Dragon
First Canadian
Green Mountain Soap
Maggard Razors Brand
Mike's Natural
Mystic Water
Ogallala
Shannon's Soaps
Soap Commander
Stirling
Strop Shoppe
Tiki

CRSW
Mikes
B&M
Soap Commander
Strop Shoppe
Tiki

Haven't tried the others

I haven't tried some of these, but I'm pretty sure which ones I'm voting for:

1. Stirling
2. Mike's Natural
3. Barrister & Mann

However, if we're talking about scent, B&M is close to tops.

Well, though I've used many soaps, I've used exactly two of the brands listed,

1- Mike's Natural of Ann Arbor
2- Ogallala, though I prefer the aftershave to the soap

I've only heard of maybe half the others, and having filled the available shelves with other stuff I haven't been out much. So, with that piteous contribution, I am subscribed and all ears ..

Mikes natural
Panna Crema
CRSW
Barrister and Mann
Soap commander
Strop Shoppe
Tiki

Catie's Bubbles
B&M

Of the three I have tried it would have to be

B&M
Mike's
Stirling

Maggard
Strop Shoppe
Soap Commander

Mickey Lee is missing from your list. Her soaps are #1, on my face anyway.

Wow. I haven't used ANY of those.

Stirling
Mystic Water
Cold River Soap Works
Mike's Natural

Soap Commander
Catie's Bubbles
Dapper Dragon
Barrister and Mann
Tiki
Strop Shoppe

Maggard Razors Brand

After the first four on the list it gets pretty hard to rank them, as far as performance goes there's not a whole lot of difference. It's mostly in the scent department they differentiate from one another (and if scent was considered, the list would look very different). Maggard's soaps are at the far bottom because they cause my skin to burn...

I've only tried Mike's, CRSW, and B&M. All three are great. I've read good things for just about everything you have listed. I dont think you can go wrong with anything you have listed. Get samples and try them all if you can....CRSW does not offer samples.

Soap Commander
Barrister & Mann
Mike's
Stirling

Mystic Water
Strop Shoppe
Maggard
Ogallala
(I won't buy these last four again)

From what I have used:

Mike's Natural / Barrister and Mann / Mystic Water (Top Tier Soaps with Amazing Post Shave)
Strop Shoppe / Shannon's Soaps (Almost identical to the tier above, with also amazing Post Shave)
Catie's Bubbles / Soap Commander (Very good performance, just lacking in post shave)
Tiki (average in all aspects, not a bad soap)
Maggard Razors Brand (just below average in performance)
Dapper Dragon (well below average in performance, including glide and post shave)

nobody seems to have the same favorites...lol

kyles said:

nobody seems to have the same favorites...lol

Click to expand...

Nope, you won't find 2 rankings of soaps to be the same! One of the many reasons why you should just try what you think sounds enjoyable and create your own "top soaps"

MIke's
Mystic

Cold River Soap Works
Barrister and Mann
Dapper Dragon
Mikes Natural
Soap Commander
Mystic Waters
Stirling
Caties Bubbles
Strop Shoppe
Tiki
Maggard

Of all the soaps listed I'll rank the one I think is the top.

Barrister & Mann

But that's because it's the only soap on the list I have tried. In the end based on reviews they're probably all good. Just get some samples of each and try them.

B&M
Mike's
Stirling
Catie's
Maggard's
Tiki

Mike's