How about you get a poll going of ALL the lime scents and have people vote based on the ones they've TRIED.
Well all I can say is I am really disappointed in the T&H. I read so many good things about this cream on B&B and I really think I just must be doing something wrong with this cream. First off, the lather always feels thin to me no matter how little or how much H2O I use. Even worse, it falls apart from any cushion I get with it during my shave and there is almost not slickness to it what so ever. I have to admit I have not done a water test nor used it with distilled water but based on how ever other cream I use performs I feel I shouldn't have to do it with the T&H. Then on top of that, the smell of this stuff is really unappealing to me. It smells like fake lime scent to me. I am really shocked as I don't understand how this cream gets talked about so much. Maybe its way different than other T&H creams but the Lime T&H is just really bad IMHO. I would not recommend it to anyone regardless of price.
Ya gotta throw a tube of Godrey Lime in the mix. A little lower end than your picks but excellent stuff!
Jay