I don't know...you sound like you're on the fence about that one.
Aspen is very good, and if you haven't tried it, you definitely should. It's basically a "greener" version of Cool Water, and said to be reminiscent of Green Irish Tweed as well.
I have both Cool Water, and Aspen, and greatly enjoy both.
I got the Aspen at Christmas; it was a gift set of two 1.7 oz bottles for I believe $15, so a total steal!!