I'm being tempted by their Cedar and Sandalwood. Have you tried that scent? The lime seems universally praised but I'm not a fan of most like scents (but love the fruit...weird).
Proraso/CO bigelow
Musgo Real.
Both pretty equal performance wise. I LOVE the Musgo Real scent. I need to buy a tube, even if its pricy...
I've tried them all and nothing compares to biotique bio palmyra