Guy's I realize that it's nostalgic, and romantic to shave like Cary Grant did.
I enjoy a shave on the weekends with a DE or injector myself. But Come on, A Mach 3 will shave a lot closer and smoother that any DE or injector. I usually have to do 3-4 passes with my Merkur to get as close as 1 pass with a Mach 3.
The Mach 3 has no pull or tug, when used with a good brush and shave cream.
So who on here really thinks a DE will shave closer and smoother that a Mach 3?
I used to feel the very same way -- that a DE takes so much more effort to get a comparable shave to my beloved Mach3. The thing that I discovered, however, is that I couldn't shave every day with a Mach3, else my face would get irritated very quickly. And so, I had to skip a day just to "heal".
With the DE, I found that I got zero irritation (barring the use of a bum blade, such as the "vertical label" Derbys, or a bum shaving soap such as Burt's Bees), and that I could shave every day.
Does that mean that over all a DE is a lot more work? Sure it is. But, it's also so much more enjoyable -- both the after effects of the shave itself, and the pleasure of being able to pick which soap or cream to use every DAY as opposed to only 3-4 times per week. And that makes it an all-around pleasure.
Usual YMMV caveats and disclaimers, of course.
Jimmy.