I'm about to place an order for one of these two and I can't decide. If you could only choose one which one would you get? I've tried samples and like both of them.
TOBS Eton College or Mr. Taylor?
- Thread starter joshf128
- Start date
I don't know about the Mr. Taylor, love the Eton College though.
That's a real coin flipper.
- Thread starter
- #4
Yeah, I'm waiting for the first "just buy both!"
I have a gift certificate and it's only enough for one and I've already got a ton of software purchases planned (come on Razorock container...) so I don't need to order both.
I have a gift certificate and it's only enough for one and I've already got a ton of software purchases planned (come on Razorock container...) so I don't need to order both.
Just go with the Eton College.
I tried samples of both and I found them similar in both fragrance and performance. The Eton perhaps a bit more fragrant.
I prefer Eton as well
I had the exact question a few months ago and went with Eton. Same/similar performance but I found myself gravitating toward the Eton scent a little more.
Its hard to beat Eton College. I'm on my first bottle, with many others in my future.
I havent tried Eton College but TOBS in general is great!
I'm with this guy. I haven't tried either, but I do LOVE the scent of St. James.
- Thread starter
- #12
I'm supposed to be paring DOWN my options not adding new ones! Lol
I bought the whole line of TOBS samples from Garry's sample shop so I got to try them all. St James and Shaving Shop narrowly missed the cut.
I prefer Mr Taylor, but am biased towards scents containing sandalwood.
- Thread starter
- #14
Thanks all for he replies. Just pulled the trigger on Eton College.
You'll not be disappointed. TOBS EC is next up in the rotation for me tomorrow and I always look forward to it. I do encourage you to try Mr. Taylor's soon. It too is a great cream.
- Thread starter
- #16
Thanks. I used Mr Taylor this morning. I like both but couldn't decide.
I am a Mr Taylor guy for my travel shaves.
Eaton college for a little more scent.
I have both, Like them both, Eaton scent is a bit stronger scented.
Its a real toss up to which one I like better, but I think I prefer Eaton as a more summer scent and Mr. Taylor more towards the fall.
Both perform equally great!
Its a real toss up to which one I like better, but I think I prefer Eaton as a more summer scent and Mr. Taylor more towards the fall.
Both perform equally great!
I have Eton shaving cream and also the cologne. Love it.
