Both are very good although quite different: the yellow tube - wood and spice - is pretty thick, takes a bit of work to lather up, while the menthol and eucalyptus is a lot thinner and lathers very easily. Both have quite strong fragrances, and albeit only a couple goes on each, so far happy with the purchases.I have yet to try Proraso in the tube but I love Proraso Green in the tub.