Welcome to B&B; Glad to have you! Plenty of good advice above; I would emphasize watching pressure.
Everyone else's suggestion to avoid AGT for now sounds good for this case. In your strokes, let the weight of the razor do the work, or at least most of the work. Also, pre-shave oil may help. Slop on about 2 or 3 drops and work it into your skin in down-to-up strokes against gravity, then apply lather. AoS' pre shave oil is around $25 and therefore pricey. I've gotten similar results from Shave Secret, about $4.00 from Walmart. American Crew sells for around $8.00 on eBay and various outlets. As your neck heals and you gain proficiency, perhaps you can slowly introduce AGT and relegate the pre-shave preparation as optional.
Wow, you guys are incredible. I wasn't expecting this many responses. You surely helped me regain some confidence. I haven't been shaving ATG, just 2 passes of WTG and one XTG. I will spend more time getting lathered up and spend more time lathering my face. I appreciate the feedback and I will look into the articles shortly. I heard one response against the col conk, is there any other recommendations to change the products?
While I suspect that your problem is due to technique more than prep, the Col Conk soap isn't considered to be an above average product. It's inexpensive, which is certainly appealing but unfortunately it's not a top notch soap. Many would tell you to skip this product and it's not something that I'd recommend either.
I'd recommend something else like:
Phoenix Artisan ($10)
Strop Shoppe SE w/tallow ($20)
RazoRock - Mudder Focker or XXX ($10)
If budget is a major concern just pick up a stick or two of Arko for two of three bucks each, it's dirt cheap and performs outstanding. The only knock that people have against it is the cheap synthetic lemon smell.
To avoid shipping charges, you can always get a tube of C.O. Bigelow cream from Bath & Body Works for $5. It's in a green tube and it's actually rebranded Proraso Green which is a very good soap. It is a menthol soap that has a little face chill to it, it's nice. They have buy 2 get one free sales all the time if you find you like it.
I agree that slickness and minimal pressure are crucial. Uberlather (see the wiki) is the best way to get slickness from lather. It also sounds as if you may not be working up your lather long enough. Since you're not face lathering, the amount of time you spend lathering your face probably isn't the problem.
What also would help is a pre-shave application such as John Allan's Slick Water or TOBS pre-shave gel.
Please do.....Wow you all are great! Very helpful. I will adjust my technique and make sure that I am taking my time and following the process. I will let you all know how it goes and keep you updated.