Simplify your routine would be my basic advice. You don't really need alum plus witch hazel, for instance, so choose one. Many aftershaves already contain witch hazel, also.
If you have sensitive skin, you may be getting a reaction to one of these products. So, if you can, keep it simple. You can gradually add things back in after a trial period.
A basic routine for example might be warm water prep, mild soap (lightly scented or unscented), warm water rinse, bit of witch hazel, then an unscented moisturizer such as a tiny amount of Cerave lotion applied while face is damp.
If you have sensitive skin, you may be getting a reaction to one of these products. So, if you can, keep it simple. You can gradually add things back in after a trial period.
A basic routine for example might be warm water prep, mild soap (lightly scented or unscented), warm water rinse, bit of witch hazel, then an unscented moisturizer such as a tiny amount of Cerave lotion applied while face is damp.