I have a couple of vendors I favor: Captain's Choice and PAA. I look for more than just scent, I want my AS to "tone" and condition my skin, and these two lines are perfect for my skin. Favorites from each? CC Sandalwood, PAA Aqua D.
My absolute favorite balm is Taylor of Old Bond Street Mr. Taylor's After Shave Balm. It comes in a 2.5 oz. tube and should last a long time of daily use. I use it all year except during the summer. It's a little pricey but I prefer it over Proraso Sensitive and Nivea Sensitive balms.
For splashes, my hands down favorite is Pinaud Clubman Classic. I have about 8 splashes and none can compare.