questions about 2 aftershaves

1. How does the Harris Arlington splash rank on the skin-friendly alcohol splash spectrum? From what I can tell it does not have the same level of skin care ingredients as, say, Musgo or Speick, but it also doesn't seem to be just alcohol and water.

2. How heavy are the Provence Sante aftershaves? They look like splashes, but they also have shea buttter. Would they be a good alcohol-free summer option?

Thanks.

[I accidentally posted this as a reply to another thread at first. Sorry to any who were confused.]