imo, being a beginner i dont have to much exp with everything, and i dont know anything bout the HTGAM (NOW called "phoenix artisan accouterments" controversy but it would be synergy. i can do 2 swirls on that puck and great a great lather going. i am using a boar brush.
would love to try the martin de candre but unfortunately i probably wont ever be able to. way to expensive sadly. its looks pretty awesome, esp in that glass jar. being a college student with a part time job its is pretty expensive when you gotta pay for everything yourself haha. hopefully once i have a career in 4 years ill be able to..
Slight twist to answer: in hard, inhospitable water, MdC wins, but not by that much. Strop Shoppe's Special Edition, Barrister and Mann's Black Label, and LASSC are pretty darn close -- they all lather really easily and well. (Arko, too, but for some reason I don't really count Arko.)