See if the Walgreens in your area have Superior 70. It's around $2.50 for a 12 oz. bottle.
If you have a Sally's nearby, they have Master's Bay Rum for around $8 for a 15 oz. bottle. Has a nice mellow vanilla-y smell.
oh, i see Captains Choice has sample vials!!! yeah!! gonna get one of those and give it a try.
Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum - Master Bay Rum -
Where are you folks finding or ordering sample packs? I would love to try a selection before i buy big!