It's worth noting too, especially regarding 4711, Florida water etc, that those products would have been used as all purpose products when they were made, much like Bay Rum.
They predate purpose built aftershave lotions (which is why AS lotions are called such despite not resembling what we would call a lotion today)
They predate purpose built aftershave lotions (which is why AS lotions are called such despite not resembling what we would call a lotion today)