What are the Mainstays in Your Aftershave/Balm Collection?

[Valerius]

Nivea ASB, Speick AS Splash, Proraso Green, DRH Arlington in no particular order.

 

[dws]

Aqua Velva Ice Sport
Ogallala Bay Rum, Limes & Peppercorns
GFT Limes Skin Food
GFT Sandalwood Skin Food
Real Shaving Co. balm

 

[eventi]

I'm a tremendous nerd, so I tabulated the number of mentions each aftershave got.

Here's the results for the ones that appear more than once:

20 pinaud clubman
12 speick
12 aqua velva ice blue
9 pinaud vibr
9 old spice
9 nivea asb
7 proraso green
6 alt innsbruck
5 pinaud lilac vegetal
5 pinaud clubman special reserve
5 florida water
5 floid blue
5 brut
5 barbasol pacific rush
5 4711
4 tabac
4 skin bracer
4 osage rub
4 myrsol agua balsamica
4 fine american blend
4 captain's choice bay rum
4 aqua velva ice sport
3 pinaud clubman lime sec
3 ogallala bay rum
3 floid black
2 tobs eton college
2 real shaving company asb
2 proraso splash
2 myrsol f/extra
2 myrsol emulsion
2 grey flannel
2 dollar tree original
2 captain's choice cat 'o nine tails

 

[mio_cuggino]

I'm a tremendous nerd, so I tabulated the number of mentions each aftershave got.

Here's the results for the ones that appear more than once:

....

nicely played. I was just thinking about this...

 

[Penknight]

Very well done indeed! Nice work!

 

[Fenris]

I expect I'll always have Old Spice around, and I use Nivea Sensitive ASB after any splash just for a bit of extra moisturizing. I'm a huge fan of Razorock Evil Eye/King Louis for their healing properties, and I don't think I ever want to run out of those.

Fine American Blend is another I'll keep buying, but I don't actually like it as an aftershave all that much. Leaves my fave feeling kinda sticky. As a fragrance, however, it's probably my favorite. I shave at night, but I usually throw some on before work.

 

[mio_cuggino]

[...] and a endless amount of cash flow.

Oh dear, that's very dangerous...
Or the start of something amazing.
Good for you.

 

[jca86]

Haven't found an aftershave I didn't like so far but Nivea Balm, Skin Bracer, Clubman and Barbasol Pacific Rush will always be in my medicine cabinet.

 

[lowjax]

I have vulgar amount of after shaves. I go in phases, seasons, and moods. Great thread though. Enjoy!

This is worthless without pictures. Let's see them Tony!

 

[DoctorShavegood]

Anything Fine, Clubman or RazoRock.

 

[Inigo Montoya]

Floid Blue
Fine American Blend
Captain's Co9T
Proraso Green
Floid Vigoroso
Pinaud Special Reserve
Musgo Real

 

[WesternModern]

Krampert's Frostbite
Myrsol Formula K
Skin Bracer Cool Spice
Fine American Blend
La Toja
Afta Original

 

[Eeyore]

Pitralon Classic

 

[JohnFM]

I have many but the ones I always have on hand:

Speik splash (great scent and the right weight -- interesting yet refreshing)
Clubman (nostalgia in a bottle, but can seem heavy after a couple of hours)
DH Harris Windsor, Arlington, or Marlborough (high quality, refined)
Fine American Blend, Vetiver, Platinum (all superb but a tad light/dilute)
Neutrogena Sensitive Skin Post Shave Balm (great stuff, use after splash)
Nivea Revitalizing Double Action Balm with Q10 (also good after splash)
Neutrogena Oil Free Moisture Sensitive Skin (final coat -- your face will never feel tight, dry, or greasy with this)

 

[JohnSki1994]

Pinaud Clubman, Aqua Velva, Nivea sensitive ASB and Old Spice. Clubam probably gets the most use. I only use the Old Spice on Sunday mornings before church when I shave with some Old Spice soap that I ended up with in a mug. I figure the soap will last a lot longer that way. Ahhhh Old Spice Sundays. Man, I wish it was Sunday again

 

[Batman]

Fine American Blend
RazoRock XXX
Captains Choice Sandalwood
Lucky Tiger Toner
3P
Speick AS & Balm
Proraso
AOS Sandalwood Balm
Musgo Real balm
SCS Bulgarian Lavender Balm
T&H Sandalwood Balm
Weleda ASB

 

[GloryUprising]

Nivea sensitive.
Cade aftershave balm.

Thinking of adding one of the Dr Harris skin foods.

 

[Vespasian]

Geo. F. Trumper Coral Skin Food
Tcheon Fung Sing Bergamotto Neroli AS balm
4711 cologne used as an AS splash

A few others in the den, but I could live with just those three.

 

[Illadelphia]

Splashes-FINE
Balms-SOAP COMMANDER

i am a summer splash and winter balm guy. Soap commander is fantastic, having used them for about a month now.

 

[masonjarjar]

oh boy.. my rotation is very large right now, but If I had to narrow it down..

Nivea Extra Sensitive Balm
Wild Country Balm
AV Ice Blue
Barbasol Brisk (Skin Bracer clone)
Skin Bracer Cooling Blue
Clubman (four versions I have, Orig, LV, SR and Vanilla)
Masters Bay Rum
Gillette Cool Wave

if you call that narrow..