I have the Rustic Amber Vanille and the Formula T Barbershop. I would say they are ok soaps. Neither one knocks my socks off from either a scent or performance perspective. They lather ok and are reasonably slick but I have soaps that are slicker. Stirling, MWF and Haslinger come to mind. At this point I don't think I would replace them when I finish them. They aren't bad mind you and I'll keep using them to use them up.