Hanging out on this board is a cursed blessing (yeah, I know that is an oxymoron)

[Matt555]

I did a side-by-side today and could not tell much difference between Montana Red and Montana Black. I thought the opening was perhaps brighter in the new Black and it seemed to project a little better and last longer also, but I may not have applied them equally. I think you don't need to worry about Red's retirement with Black filling the void.

So it is not a different scent? I am confused know. What is the blue bottle then?

 

[erickson]

They don't have a Montana Blue for men on Basenotes or Fragrantica, but I found the following notes which are nothing like Red or Black...

Fragrance notes include: Peach, cardamom and ginger. Blended with notes of vetiver, amber and musk.

http://www.quickperfumes.com/Men-M-MONTANA-BLUE-c1_28_1173.html