You are forced to thin your soap herd to 3...which ones?

[markg]

Martin de Candre
Vintage Yardley
Tabac

 

[Legion]

Palmolive, DR Harris, MWF

 

[Redzone]

Arko
Tabac
Arko

 

[Hutch]

Cella
RazoRock XXX
P.160

 

[demaro]

Vintage Old Spice , Cella , Proraso

 

[gwav64]

This year, it's:

MWF
Valobra (stick)
DR Harris Arlington

 

[OkieStubble]

MWF
La Toja
Tabac

 

[Oscroft]

MdC Fougère
DRH Arlington
MWF

But that would leave out Cella, Tabac, Proraso, Palmolive... !

 

[Oscroft]

Actually, far from any thoughts of thinning out my soaps, seeing everyone else's favourites here is more likely to make me buy more

 

[LU02]

D.R. Harris Marlborough
Valobra shave stick
Geo F. Trumper Violet

 

[brucered]

Never tried AOS and the vintage ones are no longer in production.

Right now for soaps I'd go with.

MdC
Mystic Water
DR Harris

 

[WhiteWolf]

I'd have to to with

Tabac

Arko

Speik

 

[Graybeard57]

Mama Bear's YOBS
Mike's O/CW/BP
QCS Cayman

 

[Rohrbach]

For now it would be:
MWF
Mystic Water
La Toja

 

[watchiekong]

Mitchell's Wool Fat
Martin de Candre
Tabac stick

 

[Quigg]

Actually, far from any thoughts of thinning out my soaps, seeing everyone else's favourites here is more likely to make me buy more

I agree - like most of the threads on B&B, this thread just inspires me to try more combinations!

 

[TripleG]

Mike's Lime
Haslinger - only tried the sheep's milk with lanolin and looking forward to trying more
Wilkinson Sword blue shave stick

And I'd smuggle in a Speick stick as well.

 

[gwav64]

A change in favorites:

Arko
Valobra
MWF

 

[inspectoring]

Mdc
mdc
mdc

 

[muskus]

1. Kent/MWF for everything, lathering, slickness... even scent
2. Euro Palmolive stick
3. Proraso Red. Another great performer. Nice for winther, love the scent and skin moisturizing, plus I get a hybrid between soap and cream.

Well, thought about it for a sec and it turns out that the above three are indeed the ones I use 95% of the time anyway.