If you don't care so much about scent and something very inexpensive and easy to find.... go with a Nivea AS balm. Either sensitive skin or the regular cooling one that has a little bit of menthol in it. It's gotta be one of the best values out there. If it's a splash you're after.... I gotta say Speick or Proraso. They've got the most skin goodies in them.
Ben
Ben