What is your favorate PAA aftershave?

[doctordial]

I still have some Atomic Bay Rum abd get compliments from men and women. I tried Al Fin and I like that also. I had it on years ago and I kept getting little wisps of it and I thought to myself something or someone smells good. I didn't realize it was me.

 

[shavetrooper]

I only have two. Phoenix Lights and Cavendish. I LOVE em! Looks like every paycheck I might getting something new and Atomic Bay Rum is next on my list!

 

[LoveThatBurn]

I got a sample pack, Atomic Bay Rum and Black Label really stood out.

 

[Mr. Bonney]

I like their fruity fragrances. Immortal Peach, Rabid Banana, and Tribute (Cherry and Sandalwood). Great projection, long lasting, and all Mrs. approved!

 

[doctordial]

I only have two. Phoenix Lights and Cavendish. I LOVE em! Looks like every paycheck I might getting something new and Atomic Bay Rum is next on my list!

The Atomic Bay Rum is really nice. I have one third of a bottle of it left.

 

[JCarr]

Clasico and Atomic Age Bay Rum are my favorites followed by Atomic Pumpkin and Space Nog which are seasonal Bay Rum offerings. I have a bottle of something that was offered once a while back called Amalfi Coast. My wife likes that one a lot.

 

[rudygu]

I’ve tried several samples and most have smelled pretty good. The two that stood out the most are Atomic Age Bay Rum and Fresco.

 

[GNR]

Atomic Age Bay Rum
Pineapple Bay Rum
Classico Bay Rum
Gondolier
John Frum

I tried about 20 samples and those are my favorites. I already bought bottles of the Bay Rums and Gondolier & John Frum are next.

 

[BluesPwr]

Al Fin, Pineapple Bay Rum, Sun Down & Diver Down

 

[Shaving like a boss]

Al Fin, Pineapple Bay Rum, Sun Down & Diver Down

Al Fin and Diver Down are good. Im not a big fan of the Sun Down though. I have a few bottles of Gillette SunUp and expected Sun Down to be at least close but it wasn't.

 

[kwickone]

Fresco is da bomb (homage to Old Spice Fresh). I also really like John Frum as a musky barbershop. CaD is solid....like Fine AB but different. If you like homages, you will like Cold Spices, Diver Down, and the Doppeganger (sp?) options.

 

[Jermo]

Doppleganger Gold (Royal Mayfair dup) and Solstice are my favorites.

 

[Aomalley27]

I prefer their star jelly. Both my Old Spices and Beach AS have petty much lost their scent. (Not a storage issue as I keep them in a mini fridge.) The SJ’s are still going strong (and are $10 cheaper too!)

 

[JCarr]

I'm not a huge Sandalwood fan, although I have several including Proraso Red. I just received PAA's Tribute which is a cherry-sandalwood blend...smells great!

 

[Ad Astra]

Mega Flora, a true fougere AS. Well. That and Alpa Fougere. Both follow Houbignant Fougere Royale very closely.

AA

 

[Wereduck]

One vote for Solstice; by far my favorite of the few summer-grass scents I've seen.

Plus an honorable mention to Outdoorsman's Friend; it's the only ginger I've tried that leans more toward a sharp, candied ginger scent and less toward gingerbread.

 

[gdawg55]

For me it’s hands down Atomic Age Bay Rum.

 

[Paul Bearer]

they have a green irish tweed dupe which is intoxicating. love it.

also very high marks for The Beach and CaD

 

[Berwick12]

Any of the PAA stuff that is super floral, linear dimensional, I do not like. Just super bright, and floral and all top note stuff on me is not appealing and does not work for me. So like lilac, Lily, plumeria, etc they are not my jam.

Classico Bay rum -like
Tombstone - grew on me
Tribute - meh
The wow signal - ok
The beach - smells like the beach - okay
Supreme sandalwood science- okay
Sundown - grew on me, okay
Strange Island - love
St Martin's land -like
Speakeasy - like
Solstice - not for me
Sangre de Drago - like
Red planet - love
Porthos -? - just like
Pineapple Bay - like - wish there was more pineapple
Obliette - like
Organism 46b - dislike
Meta nectar - dislike
Mega Flora dislike
Low haiku love
John frum dislike
Java Hive - dislike
Hotel Cecil - dislike
Home on the range -? Dislike
High jump - love
Harvest Moon -dislike
Good vibrations - love
Garden of Bali dislike
frostbite meh
gondolier like
future fiction - love
fresco - not for me
first night -? - dislike
et tu- dislike
ESP-like
droid black -love
doppelganger Black label- meh doppelganger tricolor - ok
doppelganger gray label - love doppelganger Gold label - not for me doppelganger f bombs -?
Diver down - love
dapper dock doc- dislike
d a b -?
Copali-like
controversy - like
Cold spices - Love
Coconut Bay - like
club guy -?
Cella cool - not for me
Captain Smyth reserve-like
CAD - Dislike
boomtown Bay rum -like
blackbot- like
big shave Southwest 2020-like
big shave East - meh
awesome sauce - meh
atomic age bay rum-like
Atmotic-?
Al fin - not for me
agharta -not for me