What's new

Rum Tasting Notes

Perhaps I should have relegated these to the "Drinking Tonight" or "Acquisitions" thread. But I found having tequila tasting notes--at least mine-- broken out separately, to be useful, so I thought I would open a separate thread. If the Mods disagree, they, of course, have my blessing to consolidate this post within one of the existing Speakeasy threads.

We spent the week over-lapping the last part of December and the beginning of January in Puerto Rico. We drank a fair amount of rum there, but did not visit any distilleries or focus much on trying to taste various things. I guess I am not a huge rum afficionado, and I think I would have said that I tended toward high hogo rums made in places like Jamacia, Barbados, and, I guess, Trinidad, and the French island rhum agricoles, mostly served in tiki-type and similar cocktails. I suppose DR rums, too, although my recollection of them is more limited. My familiarity with Cuban rums is limited, and I have not been that impressed. They seem similar to what I had had heretofore from PR, which had been mostly Bacardi, as I recall. and had not impressed me either. I do really like Ron Abuelo, in various expressions, which is Panamanian, as I recall. Interesting distilled from both can juice and molasses musts or washes or whatever the liquid distilled is called, if I recall. What is it called? As I recall Ron Abuelo seems similar to the various Venezuelan rums, which I also like.

Anyway, I brought back these three and was impressed with each on different levels:

Don Q blanco--Very much like Bacardi, but seems better to me. Very clean. Maybe more complex and flavorful than Bacardi. What one might think a rum flavor would be. No off notes at all. Seems to be available readily enough near me for about $15 for 750 ml, which is less than Bacardi.

Don Q 2009--Distilled in 2009, aged in wood until bottled and released in 2019. Single barrel, as I recall. Really, really good. Very smooth. Very flavorful. Sippable, for sure. No hogo. Very accessible, yet very complex. The wood plays very nice here. Around $62 for 750 ml at the San Juan airport, as I recall. Comes across as a very refined and high end spirit.

Don del Barrilito 3 Star--Don Del Barrilito is a step up from Bacardi and Don Q basic spirits anyway. This one is less nuanced and perhaps less complex than the on Q 2009, but still quite refined. Very nice rum. Easily accessible.
 
I have found that rum offers an exceedingly broad array of possibilities and expressions. As it is not terribly in vogue, it generally punches higher than its price point when compared to, e.g., bourbon. (Who remembers when, not all that long ago, quality bourbon was a ‘steal’ compared to quality scotch?) Plus, ‘the good stuff’ in the rum world is much more readily available than the Kentucky cousins.

Whereas a $50 bottle of bourbon might afford an 8 year old expression of something ‘good’, that same outlay might get a 15 year old expression of something sublime from the Caribbean.

I enjoy the earthy, nutty hogo, yet also enjoy the spectrum, from caramel and raisin tones enjoyed neat, to the vegetal agricole with a mixer. Spiced rum does nothing for me, but to each their own. Recently, I have been on a kick with Dictador’s offerings.

Ya Mon!
 

Doc4

Stumpy in cold weather
Staff member
As it is not terribly in vogue, it generally punches higher than its price point

Plus, ‘the good stuff’ in the rum world is much more readily available than the Kentucky cousins.

The flip side of that is ... since rum isn't terribly in vogue as a "refined sipper" ... it's very hard to find anything on shelves around here that isn't meant to be one half of a rum&coke.

Maybe if I lived in the Big City and had ready access to the fancy specialist liquor store ("Booze-tique", if you will) I would be able to find "the good stuff". And yes, from what I know, the high-end sippers in the rum world are far more affordable than their Kentucky/Islay counterparts.
 

Old Hippie

Somewhere between 61 and dead
About a quarter-century ago I found myself temporarily in Miami with the enthusiastic company of a colleague from Puerto Rico who heard that I was on the hunt for rums. She took me under her wing and we mostly blew off the conference we were attending to focus on A) rum, B) Cuban sandwiches and C) whatever looked good for dessert (who's never done that?).

So I don't remember at this late date what we actually had across a week of sampling, but it was from all over the Caribbean and I began to see some national similarities in the offerings. I remember I flew home with a couple large jugs of rum (Haitian and Barbados) gurgling in my backpack, back in the days when you could fly with more than just the underwear you were wearing. :rolleyes:

Screech, which we say is "Newfoundland Rum" but actually it's Jamaican, I believe, is my usual go-to these days. Occasionally I'll have a glass of Gosling's Black Seal -- but that enchantingly deep molasses taste only lasts for the first sip for me and after that I might as well be drinking Screech. :)

By the above you may infer I'm not a true connoisseur. Maybe not, but what I like, I like. :)

O.H.
 
The flip side of that is ... since rum isn't terribly in vogue as a "refined sipper" ... it's very hard to find anything on shelves around here that isn't meant to be one half of a rum&coke.
I have been thinking about responding to this for some time, but I was not sure what to say. I am sure the same is true of tequila. There is a huge variety of rum available near me, it is true. And it is not even a matter of just "refinded sippers." I like the mixes of rums required for real tiki drinks! There is some amazing rum in the world! I should count my blessings!

I am not sure why tequila has come to be more of a sipper than rum has for me.
 
I love sipping a good rum aged at least part of it's life in bourbon barrels. My go-to recently has been Planteray (formerly Plantation) Barbados 5yr rum. Aged 3 yrs in bourbon casks, and 2 in Ex-Ferrand casks. I often find the tasting notes of a good rum are more complex and varied than many whiskies.
 
Top Bottom