What's new

J&M Shoes - There was a time...

johnniegold

"Got Shoes?"
When I first started buying dress shoes for work, after entering the workforce in 1988, I started out with the Florsheim Royal Imperial shoes because that is what my dad used to wear.

Afterwards, I discovered Johnston & Murphy and began to acquire many of their Crown Aristocraft and Aristocraft models, many of which I still have and wear as well as some of their beef-roll pennies and some of their more casual walking shoes from the Estate Collection (another one that has gone by the wayside, unfortunately). As time went on, I eventually discovered Aldens and that is where my loyalty currently lies.

As for J&M, over the years I heard that their excellent quality was a thing of the past. There was a time when J&M made outstanding shoes.

The following photos are a pair of J&M's from their Northampton Collection. These shoes are approximately 10 years old (maybe more). I believe that this particular collection was a short-lived attempt by J&M to make shoes along the lines of Alden and some of the other fine British shoemakers.

The quality and craftsmanship of this particular shoe is first-rate. Although I am not as familiar with the J&M line as I once was, it appears that they moved away from this type of shoe-crafting.

























Too bad, really. These are a fine pair of shoes.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
They are nowhere near the quality they were in years past. I have a modern pair of their saddle bucks, but sadly they can't be re-soled.
 
Too bad, indeed. The two pairs I've owned were clearly made for a throwaway world. Yours look fantastic, though!
 
I've got three pair of J&M shoes that I've had for 15-20 years ... each have had a full resole at least once and only one pair of the three is nearing end of life. Biggest problem is that my shoe repair guy is having a hard time getting good soles these days, and he won't put junk on a good pair of shoes.

J&M used to be a great pair of shoes, but those days are no longer. My newer shoes are Allen Edmonds, and one pair of Aldens that sort of fell into my lap.
 

Doc4

Stumpy in cold weather
Staff member
Sadly, it's a lot easier for a shoe company (or any manufacturer) to slide down the quality ladder than to climb up it.

We can spend all day listing the brands that have gone downhill ... and about five minutes listing the few that have gone the other way. ... all the more reason to patronise the ones that make the upward effort when you find them!!
 
J&Ms definitely used to be good. I always snatch up vintage J&Ms when I find them in my size. Right now I'm wearing vintage J&M black & oxblood saddle shoes.
 
I could not agree more with this post. I was given my first pair of aristocrats in 8th grade, and just last year they had to go after being refurbished twice. Now I cant even bring myself to go inside a JM store. Their staff has never offered to help with anything, and I even wrote a letter to bring this to help bring it to light....no response.

Since I am in Allen Edmunds country I have switched my focus to them... And I love my Park Avenues!
 
Top Bottom