You should NEVER assume that because someone else doesn't like something, it's not good. Especially in something as personal as scent. I love the scent of Speick and I don't care what anyone else thinks of it.
The problem was that every time I didn't assume, and just tried it out for myself. And it always just reminded me of a scent that would go much better with someone twice my age or more. So now I take every review of a scented product here much more carefully, and look for things that I feel are a sure fire choice that I would have picked in the first place. There is nothing wrong with that. Speick is just not for me. Although other then the scent, its a great shave.