I was looking at the various bottles of Thayer's at the health food store - they have aloe vera, lemon, and rose. The labels on the aloe and the lemon say astringent, which is what I need... but the rose only says toner. Being witch hazel, shouldn't this be an astringent as well? I haven't smelled the aloe vera, but if I had to choose between lemon and rose, I'd go for the rose. Lemon is just way too potent and I don't want to reek of Pledge.