best barbershop scent?

American
Rive Gauche
Clubman
Brut (glass bottle)
Tabac Original EDC
Canoe

European
Antico Caruso

Stephan Bay Rum AS DOES qualify, as I've seen it described as a "true barbershop classic". I have some myself, as part of my "collection-rotation".

It'll always be Lilac Vegetal for me. Though I wear Trumper Limes daily.

Pinaud Clubman Original
Myrsol F/Extra
Pinaud Clubman Lilac Vegetal
Tabac
Pinaud Clubman Lime Sec
TOBS Victorian Lime
Bay Rum