I was curious if anyone knew the difference between these 3 variants of Thayers Witch Hazel; especially in terms of their main ingredients. I picked up a bottle of the Original formula from Whole Foods (my other choices would have been Lemon or Rose Petal) and I like it, but I was a little disappointed in the alcohol content. It reportedly contains 10% alcohol, but I could not feel the slightest burn even when applying over a open cut. If had done the same with aqua velva, it would have lit me up. I am not looking for pain, but I do enjoy the cooling sensation and feedback of the alcohol. The Thayers website doesn't go into any great detail about the difference between these products in terms of the percentage of witch hazel content versus any other ingredient. One can see that the After Shave contains more twice as much alcohol (20%) the Original formula but is that the only change, and was it at the expense of the Witch Hazel? The Medicated Superhazel has additional ingredients which sound good, but there is no way to judge if these are only included at trace amounts or are something that really helps. I will probably try the Medicated version next, but hoped to get feedback from someone who has used them or knew more details. Thanks.