Sorry, for some reason I missed this post!
Ok Mr. Sidney.... well, first off I am sure it is not mentioned much, as it is one of the more uncommon scents, it is not available in shaving cream form, and it's name is indescript - meaning #74Limes.... you can kinda guess what the general scent is going to be.... lime.... where as with Sidney's, you are totally guessing.
I took the plunge awhile back and figured i'd give it a go, and by all means it is quite nice stuff.... it just doesn't really "stand out" as anything that superb to my nose at least. It is a mint/menthol like scent... actually it smells incredibly similar to and looks quite like Scope (green) mouthwash. Now that might "sound" negative/bad, but bear with me... it isn't. Think of Mr. Taylors - with some mint/menthol added. It is a nice scent... and pretty original.... it just doesn't do a whole lot for me... at all. I enjoy it, and I wear it from time to time, but I wouldn't outwardly recommend it, or go into a rant about how incredible it is (as I would with Mr. Taylors) but it is nice stuff.
Bottom line.... it's nice, but I'd say pass on it. It isn't popular and widely discussed for a reason
joel (at) badgerandblade.com