Which Old Spice AS should I pick it up?

Hi friend,
I love old school AS very much, but it must be in glass bottles.
I find many Old Spice AS at G&C in glass bottles, they are original, champion, and whitewater.
Please suggest me which one should I pick?
Your suggestions are greatly appreciated.

Hard to go wrong with original!

I've got Old Spice Original, Old Spice Musk & Old Spice Fresh Lime
All 3 are in 150ml glass bottles
I got all 3 of mine from Indian sellers on eBay for less than €12 per bottle with free delivery to Spain

You must be from Europe, because those scents are not available in the US. I was lucky enough to find Whitewater when I was in Afghanistan, and it's nice, but you should definitely start with the original, if you have to choose just one. The true answer is, you need to pick them all!

Has anyone used or know anything about these Old Spice aftershave varieties:
http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-100-ml-5410076470686.html
http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-150-ml-4015600859626.html
http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-100-ml-4015600314637.html
http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-100-ml-4015600859565.html
http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-100-ml-5000174000634.html
http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-150-ml-4015600859749.html

I've only seen them on Gifts and Care's website (which would be expensive to ship to the US, given how quickly the weight of aftershaves adds up), and am curious what they're like. There are no scent descriptions on the site, and the names are not self-explanatory at all.

They even have the original in 100ml, 150ml & 250ml. It says Made in Germany. Has anyone tried the German made Old Spice scents?

http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-100-ml-5011321772335.html

TheVez2 said:

You must be from Europe, because those scents are not available in the US. I was lucky enough to find Whitewater when I was in Afghanistan, and it's nice, but you should definitely start with the original, if you have to choose just one. The true answer is, you need to pick them all!

Click to expand...

+1 Agree wholeheartedly!!!!

Original, Burley, Leather, Musk and Talcum... Get your MAN ON!!!

They're all nice but try original first!

mmaggi said:

They even have the original in 100ml, 150ml & 250ml. It says Made in Germany. Has anyone tried the German made Old Spice scents?

http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-100-ml-5011321772335.html

Click to expand...

View attachment 707458
Yep, I'm using the original older version German Old Spice before they've changed the formula a bit. I like it a lot and to me it has a bit more of a clove and baby powder scent compared to the American OS.

chris100 said:

Has anyone used or know anything about these Old Spice aftershave varieties:
http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-100-ml-5410076470686.html
http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-150-ml-4015600859626.html
http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-100-ml-4015600314637.html
http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-100-ml-4015600859565.html
http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-100-ml-5000174000634.html
http://www.giftsandcare.com/en/afte...-old-spice-original-150-ml-4015600859749.html

I've only seen them on Gifts and Care's website (which would be expensive to ship to the US, given how quickly the weight of aftershaves adds up), and am curious what they're like. There are no scent descriptions on the site, and the names are not self-explanatory at all.

Click to expand...

I tried Old Spice Swagger and Hawkridge last Christmas - they were both ok in themselves, but they could have been anything and didn't even bear any passing resemblance to Old Spice Original
I used up the Swagger and Hawkridge as quickly as possible to free up some shelf space for 150ml bottles of Old Spice Original, Fresh Lime and Musk from India to replace the 50ml bottles that I'd bought to try out and liked

If you into collecting things, I think a bottle of every different variety of Old Spice in existence would look cool stood side by side on a shelf, but IMHO out of the ones that I've tried out, the Indian made Old Spice Original, Musk & Fresh Lime were the best, and all had the same Old Spice style of scent, the Canadian made Old Spice Classic was ok, but 2nd fiddle compared to Original

And that giftsandcare website charges only 5.60 euros to ship to the US. Their prices are very reasonable.

Bearglove, Wolfthorn, lionpride, Swagger.... these are Old Spice's newer scents, aimed at the younger generation of Axe body spray users. They don't have the aftershaves, but Walmart carries all of these scents in body sprays, deodorants, and body washes. I've smelled them all, and wouldn't want to use them as an aftershave.

I am curious about Champion though.

Tough question as I like them all! I suggest starting with the original.

To address the OP's topic, I have the lime from India. Very nice scent that stays with you for most of the day. I also have the lime cream (nice scent, ok performance -- I didn't realize that the performance was mediocre until trying GFT, Derby, and Speick creams).