Longest lasting Old Spice Scent?

I recently got a sample of Stirling Spice, and was quite impressed. However, the scent disappears and that is sad.

Do either the American or Indian Old Spices last longer than Stirling Spice? What about Indian Old Spice Musk?

I guess my basic question is: what is the strongest, best Old Spice aftershave that is currently available?

Thanks!!

I recently used up the last of my Canadian Old Spice Classic, the Old Spice Original from India smells much better
I've also got Old Spice Musk & Fresh Lime from India.
All 3 are fairly strong when I put them on, but all 3 fade within a couple of hours
If anything, the Fresh Lime is the strongest

I get six hours from the Classic and a bit longer from the Indian Original and Fresh Lime.

Try the Family Dollar knock-off made by Vi-Jon.

I find Avon Spicy to have staying power. I know it isn't being made any more, but it is one of the easier scents to find. And usually dirt cheap, around here anyway. It's also available on the bay.

BSAGuy said:

Try the Family Dollar knock-off made by Vi-Jon.

Click to expand...

Can an also be found in shop rite for $2 or CVS for $8 (same exact product)

Thanks guys. Sounds like Indian is the way to go!

I have some Old Spice Fresh aftershave. I can detect its' citrusy aquatic scent 6 to 7 hours after application. This stuff has been in my shaving cabinet for several years. I got it out to try last week and soon I was asking myself why I haven't been using this more. A nice summery scent which projects out pretty well, got a compliment and an inquiry about it too. I recommend this now that I am using it, also a deodorant is available. You won't have to worry about smelling bad or funky with Fresh.

Although the Vi-Jon version has a better scent than the P&G version, it only lasts a couple of hours on me. P&G lasts much longer.

Argh...conflicting reports!

BSAGuy said:

Try the Family Dollar knock-off made by Vi-Jon.

Click to expand...

That one has no longevity at all. Maybe an hour, at best.

TheVez2 said:

That one has no longevity at all. Maybe an hour, at best.

Click to expand...

I found that when I mixed Stirling Spice, with the New Old spice, it lasted a long time. YMMV due to body chemistry. but it smelled like I remember it, and lasted all day.

mscout00 said:

I found that when I mixed Stirling Spice, with the New Old spice, it lasted a long time. YMMV due to body chemistry. but it smelled like I remember it, and lasted all day.

Click to expand...

One to one ratio?

I also have seen that the pg modern old spice mixed with the dollar store smells good too

CzechCzar said:

I also have seen that the pg modern old spice mixed with the dollar store smells good too

Click to expand...

It's OK. Your best bet is vintage Avon Spicy, which is very readily available, and usually for cheap. It's a clone of the Shulton formula, so if you can't find the real thing, this is what you want. Avon Brisk Spice is even better, but harder to find.

TheVez2 said:

It's OK. Your best bet is vintage Avon Spicy, which is very readily available, and usually for cheap. It's a clone of the Shulton formula, so if you can't find the real thing, this is what you want. Avon Brisk Spice is even better, but harder to find.

Click to expand...

So you would say that that beats Indian old spice in terms of longevity? If so I can just pick some up off that other site

mscout00 said:

I found that when I mixed Stirling Spice, with the New Old spice, it lasted a long time. YMMV due to body chemistry. but it smelled like I remember it, and lasted all day.

Click to expand...

Sometimes I just use PG OS cologne as an after shave for a longevity kick. The ingredients are essentially the same.

August West said:

Sometimes I just use PG OS cologne as an after shave for a longevity kick. The ingredients are essentially the same.

Click to expand...

Yeah, I have the cologne, and love it. That is why I want an aftershave that matches.

With the stirling, i matched splash for splash in my hand. rubbed it together and then onto my face.