Aftershaves with witch hazel - suggestions?

sarimento1 said:

Thayers medicated witch hazel is exactly what you want!

Click to expand...

How does this differ from the regular flavors?

Very neutral scent. Slightly camphor or perhaps eucalyptus. Aloe. To my nose, no alcohol.

Anything from K shave Worx. Most replenishing aftershave I've ever used

sarimento1 said:

Very neutral scent. Slightly camphor or perhaps eucalyptus. Aloe. To my nose, no alcohol.

Click to expand...

correction, just checked ingreds, does contain alcohol, but very mild.

+3. Lucky Tiger, great juice IMHO!

Thayers works great and has a variety of fragrances, including unscented. Another excellent one is Nancy Boy gel. One that I haven't tried but others seem to like is Provence Sante splash. None of these is too pricey either.
Happy hunting.

I do really enjoy Stirling Witch Hazel and Aloe, has a great deal of menthol punch as well in the Orange Chill.

However no no one has mentioned the two new and big contenders in this catagory and they are Cold River Soap Works Lotion and Chatlitton Lux toner. Check them out