Royalle Bay Rhum and VIBR are my tops
Which is your Favorite Bay Rum Aftershave
- Thread starter Vintage Doc
- Start date
I just checked the website. $26 for the bottle and $10 for shipping. That's mighty steep....unless someone can convince me it is THAAAAAAT good....
- Thread starter
- #63
You have to admit that little razor blade on there is pretty cute....haha
DR Harris . Still the sweet one for me
Bootlegger's Original
I used to live the Dominica Bay rum. Though since it's been discontinued my go to is Captain's Choice
Clubman VIBR is best; tho I haven't tried Gabels.
When was it discontinued?? I bought a bottle a couple of months ago. IIRC, it was "unavailable" (for reasons unknown, to me anyway) for a while, and I had a little trouble finding it in stock. But (again IIRC) production/sale had been resumed.
Anyway...it's a good one!
I'd be unhappy if I were unable to buy any more.All that said...Captain's Choice is a great BR...I especially like the CO9T!
Last year, must've been around November. I was searching for it and couldn't find it. I read somewhere that it was discontinued for whatever reason. I went to grab some at WCS.When was it discontinued?? I bought a bottle a couple of months ago. IIRC, it was "unavailable" (for reasons unknown, to me anyway) for a while, and I had a little trouble finding it in stock. But (again IIRC) production/sale had been resumed.
Anyway...it's a good one!
All that said...Captain's Choice is a great BR...I especially like the CO9T!
http://www.westcoastshaving.com/Dominica-Original-Bay-Rum-Aftershave-Lotion_p_215.html
However, thanks to you saying you got it a couple months back, I was able to find it at what I assume is the distributor.
got my order in of derby city . epic bay rum. sweeter just like I enjoy although heavy on cinnamon. a little artistan like. thumbs up.
Last edited:
50/50 mix of Pinaud VIBR & Master BR. Very nice. Decanted mine into an empty Pepsi Bottle. Used the VIBR Label.
No votes for TOBS Bay Rum? I have that and Captain's Choice CO9T and find TOBS very good.
Haven't tried many, but another vote for captain's choice bay rum. Nice, mild, earthy (well, and my wife likes it).
Captains Choice North, also Ogallala Sage & Cedar and Lime & Peppercorn right behind. The Ogallalas give my face a nice soft feeling afterwards and have great staying power. Just what you need to faceterbate.
Vintage 1962 Avon Bay Rum in the real colored jug. FEEL the burn!
Magic in a Bottle.
That's what I call Captains Choice Cat-o-nine Tails. This is magic in a bottle. Razor burn obliterator.
It's my 911 of aftershaves.
That's what I call Captains Choice Cat-o-nine Tails. This is magic in a bottle. Razor burn obliterator.
It's my 911 of aftershaves.
George Trumper Bay Rum has a great scent, but it doesn't last. That can be a good thing, depending on your circumstances. Clubman's Bay Rum starts out smelling great, natural and traditional, but then its scent modulates to a musky smell that I don't associate with BR.
Gilbert Henry is really good. The cologne is especially long lasting. Gabel's is probably the best buy, but it doesn't last either.
Gilbert Henry is really good. The cologne is especially long lasting. Gabel's is probably the best buy, but it doesn't last either.
I have only tried two, Ogallala and Pinaud. I prefer Ogallala hands down. It has a great scent that is long-lasting.
