First of all. Thanks everyone. I guess I'm not sure what to compare it to in order to give you an idea on how thin it is. The recipe I made was 2.5 teaspoons grapeseed oil, 1.5 tsp jojoba oil, 1 tsp Argan oil, .5 tsp Avocado oil and .5 vitamin e oil. Based on your response it sounds like this may be a good recipe. It's hard for me to know if I've made a good or bad recipe because I have never previously used beard oils. I've thought about offering a PIF for my homemades to get some input but I feel like that may be breaking some rules around here, which is the last thing I want to do because I really enjoy interacting with the B&B community