Floid (Blue and The Genuine), and it's not close. I have a bottle of original Clubman, and I rarely reach for it. Depending on my mood, Clubman can smell classic or it can smell like a cheap cologne. The Clubman label says it cools, but I don't get that feeling at all. In fact, I get a warming sensation from Clubman. I love the cooling, refreshing feeling of Floid. I want to love Clubman because it is a classic product, somewhat of an icon in the wet shaving community, but it just doesn't do it for me. But Floid, I'll take that to the deserted island.
Floid by a mile. This is wholly subjective but I like the scent of Floid and just don't like Clubman. I actually poured half a bottle of Clubman down the sink - I don't like it that much. Blasphemy, I know.