Well Brandon's under-rated thread instantly made me think of a lot more contentious thread topic:
What do you think is the most over-rated, over-hyped shave cream or soap?
From what I have used to date I would cast a vote for Tom's Peppermint. Compared to everything else I have tried, it is by far my least favorite, least fun cream.
Naturally every post in this thread should end with YMMV, IMHO, ASAP, PDQ, XYZ, etc...