List your staple products - 1 per category and runner-up!

Soap: Tabac puck

Razor: Lord L6

Brush: L'Occitaine Plisson Synthetic

Blade: Personna Blue

AS: Tabac A/S (though I do use Dickenson's WH before applying A/S)

Soap- DR HARRIS Arlington
Razor- EJ DE89 / RazoRock SLAB
Brush- Semogue 620
Blade- Astra SP
AS- RazoRock XX

only been wet shaving a month and a half and been getting great results with these items

Soap: 1. Cella 2. RazoRock XXX
Blade: 1. Personna Med Prep 2. Gillette 7 O'Clock
Brush: 1. Pure Badger 2. Boar
AS: 1. Witch Hazel + TOBS Jermaine St

Cream: Barbon
Razor: EJ 89Lbl
Blade: Polsilver Super Iridium
Brush: Golden Nib Silver tip
AS: Clubman Original
ASB: Nivea for Men Energy

These aren't necessarily my favorite, but they are reliable and I will probably always have them in my cabinet.

Soap: Tabac
AS: Nivea balm for sensitive skin
Razor: EJ 8911
Blade: Astra SP

I have a standard set for the most part, but I'm constantly experimenting with one area. Right now, I'm mostly experimenting with soaps

Soap: Varies, but when I need to set a baseline I'm recently been using Tiki Peppermint Bark Tallow. Caties Bubbles Two to Mango used to be my baseline but I traded it for some LPV which ended up causing me irritation, so I traded that away, etc. etc. Mystic Waters has also played this role, but I've just about used up all my samples

Brush: L'occittaine plisson synthetic (backup: EJ silvertip synth)
Bowl: Dollar Tree Salsa Bowl (I LOVE this bowl!)
Razor : Muhle R41 (2013) (Backup: NEW)
Blade: Feather (backup: Polsilver SI or Astra SP)
Post shave: Alum block and Witch Hazel. Sometimes Myrsol Antesol as AS. Usually nothing

Soap: Cella
Cream: CF Lavender
Brush: EJ BBB
AS: Proraso
Blade: Feather

Soap: MdC Fougere, AOS Sandalwood Tallow
Razor: Merkur Mergress, 34c
Brush: chubby 3 Manchurian in Jade, ch 3 Manchu in
Briar
Blade: Astra SP
A/S: Simpsons AS balm, floid blue

soap: arko
cream: tobs
razor: merkur 34C
blade: lab blue
asb: nivea

Muhle R89 (1), Weber (2)
Razo Rock soap
Astra SP
Morris & Forndran 2-band
Speick (1), Myrsol Aqua Balsamica (1A)
Neutrogena balm or moisture

Razor: Above The Tie Kronos H2
Blade: Personna Lab
Brush: Morris & Forndran "Chief"
Soap: Barrister & Mann Leviathan
Aftershave: Barrister & Mann Kyovu
Balm: Barrister & Mann Wonderbalm

Today's list (subject to change daily):

Soap/Cream: 1. George F Trumper cream (any scent) 2. Through The Fire soap (any scent)
Razor: 1. Gillete Slim 2. Fatip Grande
Brush: 1. Cade Plisson
Blade: 1. Polsilver SI 2. Gillette 7 O'clock Yellow
AS: 1. Pinaud VIBR 2. Cade A/S Balm

Soap: MdC
Cream: TOBS
Brush: Plisson Synthetic
Razor: DE89/R89
Blade: Astra SP
Aftershave: Nivea Repleneshing

Hmm. If I understand the request--listing the Old Reliables that will always perform with no surprises--these would be mine:

Soap: Mike's/Speick
Razor: EJ89/Slim
Brush: WD Silvertip/Omega Boar
Blade: Astra SP/7O'Clock Black
AS: Thayer's Superhazel/RR Don Marco Milk

Razor: Muhle R41...MergressXL
Brush: Simpson Colonel...Omega B&B essential boar
Blade: Feather...Personna Med Prep
Soap: Mitchell's Wool Fat...RazoRock XXX
Aftershave: Myrsol Emulsion...Alt Innsbruck

Gillette ss, cella, old spice, quite the heathen!

Soap 1. Tobac 2. still looking
Razor 1. Fatip grande nickol 2. Gillette tech (vintage late 30s early 40s).
Brush 1. using really cheap badger brush now, in need of expanding what I have.
Blade 1 Astra SP 2. Gillette sharp edge (yellow)
AS 1 nivea AS balm for sensitive skin 2. none

Soap: 1. Mitchell's Wool Fat 2. T&H 1805 cream

Razor: 1. FaTip Grande 2. '56 Flare Tip

Brush: 1. Simpson Harvard H4 2. Omega 48

Blade: 1. Gillette Silver Blue 2. Gillette 7 O'clock Black

AS: 1. Fine Fresh Vetiver 2. Fine American Blend

During the past weeks my standard setup has changed quite a bit:

Merkur 37C - Astra SP
Tabac Soap
Simpsons Commodore X3
Nivea Sensitive ASB

Soap: Tabac
Brush: custom badger brush
Razor:Fatboy / Apollo
Blade: what ever I have