A/S Tonics

Okay, I've read great reviews regarding aftershave tonics and the results when combining them with an A/S balm. So my question to you is, for those who've tried at least two of these, which tonic is your preferred.

-QED DaVinci Water
-Thayer's witch hazel
-Hydrolast Summer Sage

Which have you had success with, and are they compatible with any balm?

QED but I use Thayes more, the only reason..... Price. I use QEDs hydrosols when I am feeling good on the weekends.