+1 ... Google says Dean Martin is being shaved by Angie Dickinson in the movie Rio Bravo.Looks more like Dean Martin to me.
Witch Hazel perhaps.The "Jeris Talc" still available as well. I'm somewhat curious as to what is the shaving product the white container labeled, "W. H."
In that pic of Jeter, the Mach-Whatever doesn't look like it took off any stubble at all.